Description:

Not psychosis - why maladaptive daydreaming should not be confused with schizophrenic disorders and how to tell the difference between the two.

Related

• Maladaptive daydreaming - causes, symptoms and help

• Trauma and maladaptive daydreaming - a survival mechanism? (10)

• Dissociation or maladaptive daydreaming? What are the differences? (9)

• Myths and misconceptions about maladaptive daydreaming (7)

Teaser (Lead)

"Am I crazy?" Many people affected by maladaptive daydreaming ask themselves this question. The intense immersion in fantasy worlds can sometimes appear psychotic to outsiders. But the difference is fundamental! This article explains why MD is not a psychotic disorder - and how experts distinguish between the two.

Psychotic disorders and maladaptive daydreaming: a critical distinction

First, read the detailed main article [Maladaptive daydreaming - understanding, treating and overcoming it]

or

The overview "Maladaptive daydreaming - causes, symptoms and help". This topic article clarifies the critical difference between psychotic disorders.

1 The fundamental difference: Reality testing remains intact

The crucial difference lies in reality testing: while people with psychotic disorders have a distorted perception of reality or develop delusions, in maladaptive daydreaming, the perception of reality remains intact.

In psychotic disorders:

• No insight into the illness

• Conviction that delusions are real

• Hallucinations are experienced as real sensory impressions

In maladaptive daydreaming:

• Complete insight: sufferers know that they are "only" fantasies

• Clear separation between dream and reality

• No real hallucinations or delusions

2. typical risks of confusion - and why they are wrong

Reason for confusion 1: "Absorption"

• Psychosis: Patients are involuntarily trapped in their symptoms.

• MD: Patients consciously and intentionally immerse themselves in their fantasy worlds.

Reason for confusion 2: Emotional intensity

• Psychosis: Emotions result from delusions or hallucinations

• MD: Emotions are self-generated and controllable

Reason for confusion 3: Social withdrawal

• Psychosis: Withdrawal due to paranoia or fear of persecution

• MD: Withdrawal to maintain fantasy worlds, not out of fear

3. Case studies: How experts differentiate

Case of Maria (42): Maladaptive daydreaming

• Dreams of a parallel world for 4-6 hours a day

• Describes her fantasy characters in detail

• Knows exactly: "It's only in my head"

• Interrupts immediately when spoken to

• No antipsychotic medication necessary

Case of Thomas (38): Paranoid schizophrenia

• Hears voices calling him names

• Believes neighbours want to poison him

• Is convinced: "This is really happening!"

• Reacts aggressively to reality cues

• Needs antipsychotics

4 Why the distinction is so important

For treatment:

• Psychosis: medication (antipsychotics) necessary

• MD: Psychotherapy, no medication indicated

For the prognosis:

• Psychosis: chronic course, often relapses

• MD: good prognosis with therapy, no chronification

For those affected:

• Wrong diagnosis → wrong treatment → deterioration

• Correct diagnosis → appropriate help → improvement

5 Rare exception: When both come together

In sporadic cases (less than 1%), MD can occur in people who are prone to psychosis. Special caution is required here:

• MD can be a prodromal symptom[1] of psychosis.

• Intense daydreams can trigger psychotic episodes.

• Seek professional help immediately in the event of a sudden worsening

FAQ

Can maladaptive daydreaming develop into psychosis?

No, MD does not develop into psychosis. However, it can be an early warning sign in people with a corresponding predisposition.

How do I know that I am not psychotic?

The key is to realise that if you know your daydreams are fantasy, you are not suffering from psychosis.

Should I be tested for schizophrenia?

Only if there is a concrete suspicion (e.g., hearing voices, delusions) is this not necessary for pure MD.

Can medication for psychosis also help with MD?

No, antipsychotics do not work against MD and have unnecessary side effects.

What should I do if I am unsure?

Professional clarification by a GP, psychiatrist or psychotherapist.

[1] Prodromal symptom: Early warning signs that may precede a full-blown disease.