DESCRIPTION:

Impostor syndrome or fraud syndrome? Recognise toxic shame and self-doubt. You are not a fraud!

Impostor syndrome: Why successful people with self-doubt fear being exposed as frauds

Impostor syndrome is a widespread psychological phenomenon in which people have persistent self-doubt and fear being exposed as frauds despite obvious successes and competencies. This article sheds light on the scientific background of Impostor Syndrome, explains its symptoms and causes, and offers practical strategies for coping with it. Learn why it is precisely the most competent people who are most often affected by this phenomenon and how you can learn to appreciate your own achievements.

What is impostor syndrome, and how does it develop?

Impostor syndrome, also known as fraud syndrome, was first defined in 1978 by psychologists Pauline R. Clance and Suzanne Imes. It describes a psychological phenomenon in which individuals, despite obvious successes and competencies, have a subjective feeling that they do not deserve their achievements and success. People with impostor syndrome attribute their accomplishments to factors such as luck or external circumstances rather than recognising their own abilities.

The impostor phenomenon is characterised by a persistent feeling of inadequacy and an irrational fear of being exposed as a fraud. Those affected often overestimate the abilities of others while systematically underestimating their own. This discrepancy between objective competence and subjective self-perception leads to considerable psychological distress.

Research by Clance and Imes initially showed that successful women in academic and professional fields were particularly affected by this phenomenon. Today, however, we know that impostor syndrome occurs across genders and can affect people from all backgrounds who often suffer from increased self-doubt due to additional social challenges.

Why are successful people particularly affected by impostor syndrome?

Paradoxically, it is often the most competent and successful people who are most affected by impostor syndrome. These individuals typically have high standards for themselves and tend towards perfectionism, which makes them prone to self-doubt. They critically analyse their own performance and are aware of their weaknesses, while underestimating their strengths.

People with impostor syndrome often display a self-perception distorted by toxic shame: they see their own doubts, fears and insecurities, while only perceiving the successful results of others. This asymmetrical view leads them to believe that they are less competent than their colleagues or role models. In addition, these people often have a pronounced tendency to question themselves constantly.

Another factor is our brain’s negativity bias: people naturally focus more on potential shortcomings than on successes. This tendency is reinforced by a high level of motivation, which leads to a constant search for areas of improvement and a devaluation of achievements already made.

What symptoms do people with impostor syndrome exhibit?

Those affected suffer from persistent self-doubt and are sure that others will sooner or later discover their supposed incompetence. They have the irrational feeling that they are not as intelligent or capable as others perceive them to be.

People with impostor syndrome, therefore, exhibit low self-esteem. They often struggle to accept praise and recognition, frequently doubting the sincerity of positive feedback.

Other common symptoms include perfectionism, the fear of being exposed as an impostor, and the tendency mentioned above to constantly compare oneself negatively with others and systematically devalue oneself in the process. These symptoms result in considerable stress and anxiety.

How does impostor syndrome differ from other mental illnesses?

It is important to distinguish impostor syndrome from other mental disorders, although there may be some overlap. Unlike clinical anxiety disorders or depression, impostor syndrome is not an officially recognised mental disorder, but rather a psychological phenomenon that occurs in otherwise healthy individuals.

While people with impostor syndrome have specific doubts about their professional or academic competence, these self-doubts are usually situation-specific and not generalised to all areas of life. In generalised anxiety disorder, on the other hand, worries and fears extend to various aspects of life. However, impostor syndrome can lead to chronic stress and, in severe cases, contribute to the development of anxiety disorders or depression.

Another difference lies in the assessment of reality: people with impostor syndrome have objectively verifiable successes and competencies, but doubt their legitimacy. In other mental illnesses, self-perception can be generally distorted. Those affected are often aware that their self-doubt is irrational, but are still unable to overcome it, which makes the phenomenon particularly stressful.

What role does perfectionism play in impostor syndrome?

Perfectionism plays a central role in the development and maintenance of impostor syndrome. People who tend towards perfectionism set themselves unrealistically high standards and evaluate their performance extremely critically. These excessive expectations lead to even outstanding achievements being perceived as insufficient, which reinforces the feeling of being a fraud.

The connection between perfectionism and self-doubt is particularly evident in the way those affected deal with mistakes and setbacks. While perfectionists interpret normal mistakes as proof of their incompetence, people without this tendency see mistakes as a natural part of the learning process. This distorted perception leads people with impostor syndrome to systematically devalue their own performance.

Perfectionism can also lead to a vicious circle: for fear of failure, those affected prepare excessively and work harder than necessary. When they are successful, they attribute this to their excessive preparation rather than their actual competence. This cycle reinforces self-doubt and the feeling of not deserving one’s own successes, which further perpetuates impostor syndrome.

How can impostor syndrome be diagnosed and measured?

Impostor syndrome is primarily diagnosed using standardised self-assessment questionnaires, with the Clance Impostor Phenomenon Scale being the most commonly used tool. Developed by Pauline Clance, this scale measures various aspects of the phenomenon, including the tendency to minimise one’s own achievements, the fear of being discovered as a ‘fraud’ and the attribution of success to external factors.

In addition to the original Clance scale, other measurement instruments capture various dimensions of impostor syndrome. A comprehensive assessment should also include the evaluation of related constructs such as neuroticism, self-esteem, and perfectionism, as these factors often correlate with the impostor phenomenon. Psychologists and therapists also use structured interviews to gain a better understanding of the subjective experiences of those affected.

When making an assessment, it is important to take into account the cultural and social environment of the person affected. People from underrepresented groups or those who are the first in their family to pursue an academic or professional career may suffer more from feelings of impostorism. Careful examination of individual circumstances helps to develop appropriate support measures and to differentiate between impostor syndrome and other psychological stresses.

What scientifically proven strategies are there for coping with impostor syndrome?

Coping with impostor syndrome requires a multidimensional approach that combines cognitive, emotional and behavioural interventions. Cognitive behavioural therapy has proven particularly effective, as it aims to identify irrational thought patterns and replace them with more realistic assessments. Therapists help those affected to reduce their self-doubt and develop a more balanced view of their abilities.

An important strategy is to develop a more realistic attribution for one’s own successes. Instead of attributing achievements solely to external factors, those affected learn to recognise their own abilities and efforts as important factors for success. Keeping a success diary can help them gather evidence of their abilities and consciously perceive their own achievements.

Group therapy and self-help groups also play an important role in overcoming impostor syndrome. Talking to other people who have had similar experiences can be very healing and reduce feelings of isolation. In such groups, those affected often realise that their self-doubt is widespread and that many successful people are plagued by self-doubt.

How does imposter syndrome affect professional performance and career?

Imposter syndrome can have a significant impact on academic and professional careers, even though those affected are objectively competent and successful. People with this phenomenon sabotage themselves by turning down opportunities or not applying for promotions because they believe they are not qualified. This self-limitation can lead to stagnation in career development, even though the potential for further success is there.

Another problematic aspect is the tendency to overwork as a compensatory mechanism. People with impostor syndrome work hard to compensate for their perceived shortcomings. Burnout and health problems are then possible consequences. Paradoxically, this excessive effort often reinforces impostor fears, as those affected attribute their success to hard work rather than their natural competence.

Impostor syndrome can also affect team dynamics. Those affected may be reluctant to express their opinions or take on leadership roles for fear of revealing their perceived incompetence. This reluctance deprives teams and organisations of valuable contributions and can stifle innovation and creativity. Productivity in work groups suffers when competent members hold themselves back or systematically underestimate their contributions.

What can managers and organisations do to support those affected?

Managers and organisations play a crucial role in overcoming imposter syndrome in the workplace. An essential first step is to create a supportive work culture that encourages open communication about self-doubt and insecurity. When managers talk about their own experiences with imposter syndrome, they can create an atmosphere in which employees feel safe to share similar feelings.

Regular and specific feedback is essential to help people with imposter syndrome assess their performance realistically. Instead of just giving general praise and recognition, managers should provide specific examples of good performance and explain why it is valuable. That helps those affected to recognise and appreciate their own contributions.

Mentoring programmes can be particularly valuable in supporting people with impostor feelings. Experienced mentors can not only offer professional support, but also help develop realistic expectations and strengthen self-esteem. Organisations should also offer professional support, such as employee assistance programmes that provide access to psychological counselling and psychotherapy when the psychological strain becomes too great.

What is the connection between childhood trauma, toxic shame and impostor syndrome?

An often overlooked but significant aspect of impostor syndrome is its connection to early traumatic experiences and toxic shame. People who have experienced emotional neglect, criticism or trauma in their childhood often develop a fundamentally fragile sense of self-worth, which makes them particularly susceptible to impostor fears. These early experiences leave behind an inner critic and create a foundation of self-doubt that later manifests itself in professional and academic contexts as impostor syndrome.

Toxic shame differs from healthy shame in that it is not related to specific actions, but affects a person’s entire identity. While healthy shame says ‘I made a mistake,’ toxic shame conveys the message ‘I am wrong.’ People with this deep-seated sense of shame often believe that they are fundamentally flawed or inadequate, which aligns perfectly with the core beliefs of imposter syndrome. They feel like frauds because their internal conviction tells them that they are not valuable or competent enough to deserve their position.

The link between childhood trauma and later impostor syndrome is particularly evident in people who grew up in families where love was tied to performance or where they were subjected to constant criticism. These individuals have learned that their value as human beings depends on external successes, but at the same time, they develop a deep conviction that they are never good enough. As adults, they are unable to internalise their accomplishments because they contradict their damaged self-image, leading to the characteristic self-doubt of impostor syndrome.

How is research on impostor syndrome evolving?

Research on impostor syndrome has evolved and diversified considerably since the original work by Clance and Suzanne Imes in 1978. Modern studies examine not only the general mechanisms of the phenomenon but also the specific differences between various population groups. Particular attention is paid to people from underrepresented groups, who often face additional challenges.

Current research is increasingly focusing on the neurobiological aspects of impostor syndrome and investigating how subjective experiences are reflected in brain activity patterns. In addition, scientists are exploring the role of digital media and social networks in amplifying feelings of impostor syndrome.

The development of new measurement tools and treatment approaches is also a focus of current research. While the original studies focused mainly on women, modern research shows that the phenomenon occurs across genders and can take various forms. These findings are leading to more differentiated treatment approaches that are tailored to the specific needs of different groups and take into account the role of multiple factors in coping with the syndrome.

Key points about impostor syndrome – summary

• Definition: Impostor syndrome is a psychological phenomenon in which competent people have persistent self-doubt despite their successes and fear being exposed as impostors.

• Paradox: It is often the most successful and competent people who are most affected, as they are aware of their own weaknesses but only see the successes of others.

• Origin: First described in 1978 by Pauline R. Clance and Suzanne Imes, observed initially in successful women, now recognised as a gender-neutral phenomenon

• Symptoms: Persistent self-doubt, fear of discovery, minimisation of one’s own successes, attribution of achievements to external factors such as luck

• Perfectionism: Plays a central role in the development and maintenance of the syndrome through unrealistically high standards

• Measurement: The Clance Impostor Phenomenon Scale is the most commonly used diagnostic tool

• Treatment: Cognitive behavioural therapy, group therapy and self-help groups have proven to be effective strategies for coping

• Career impact: Can lead to self-sabotage, overwork, and missed opportunities despite objective competence

• Organisational support: Managers can contribute to coping through specific feedback, mentoring, and open communication

• Current research: Focuses on neurobiological aspects, cultural differences, and the development of targeted interventions for different populations

RELATED ARTICLES:

Overcoming toxic shame: a guide to maintaining a positive self-image

Self-deception, its consequences and how to recognise self-deception

Self-defeating thought and behaviour patterns

Self-compassion and self-awareness: tried-and-tested self-care techniques